Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Bart Hilgers's avatar

Dear Anne Marie, you were absolutely right with your comment on my latest article 'The Age of Average Hotels'.

Yours is a brilliant supply-chain-level analysis of exactly the same phenomenon from a different angle. Where you follow the money through FF&E procurement and vertical integration, I followed it through OTA commodification and the loss of hotel identity at the guest-experience level. Both roads lead to the same beige lobbies, hollow marketing symbolism, destination/community-extraction and capital power. Thank you for making my argument richer. Keep on going with your mission to make people aware that they can choose more wisely and joyfully!

Mattia Ferro's avatar

This is the best breakdown of the beige problem I’ve read, Anne Marie. And it names a distinction I defend constantly.

There’s a world between subtraction and beige. Beige removes soul to cut cost and risk.

Real subtraction removes everything that competes with soul, so the one true thing can finally be felt. Same empty wall, opposite intention. One is a spreadsheet. The other is taste.

Your capital-structure point is the whole game. You can’t outsource taste to a procurement catalogue and expect a sense of place to survive it. A hotel that feels like somewhere was decided by a person who cared, long before any guest arrived.

I’m at the Delano myself in February, so I’ll report back on whether ‘Delano-white’ reads as calm or as absent. My bet, sadly: I’ll remember the light and forget the room.

Sense of place can’t be procured. It has to be lived first, by whoever built it

13 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?