Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mattia Ferro's avatar

This is the clearest map of that mess I’ve read, Anne Marie. ‘Follow the money’ should be printed above every travel feed.

One thing from the operator side. Amanvari didn’t have a marketing problem that day, it had a gate problem. All the narrative in the world means nothing if, in the one moment that tests it, the most junior person on site has no authority to make it right and a guest is left standing outside. Trust is built in the ordinary and revealed in the exception. A brand is only as trustworthy as whoever happens to be at the gate on the worst day.

And your point about who has something to lose is the whole thing. The trustworthy voice isn’t the loudest, it’s the one with a tomorrow. An anonymous account has no next year. A relationship does, and reputation only compounds for people who can’t disappear.

Seek information widely, but weight it by who pays a price if they’re wrong. That filter has never failed me.

Alyssa Morlacci's avatar

I’ve been on plenty of press trips, let me add some color!

How to get invited: Journalists are typically invited to experience a hotel by an external PR agency. That agency could rep dozens to hundreds of hotels, so you want to stay in their good graces or else you won’t be invited on future trips to other destinations.

Who pays: The agency wants you to have confirmed coverage in advance, and all expenses are covered by the hotel, including flights, food, accommodations, and excursions. There are, however, publications that do not accept press trip pitches (like the NYTIMES). But usually, journalists aren’t making enough money to have these experiences and media today isn’t an industry that can foot the bill. So when pubs don’t accept press trips, that means only a small sector of writers can afford to write about luxury travel.

The ethics: At the magazine I worked for, we had an internal policy that if we had a bad experience, we wouldn’t write a bad review — we just wouldn’t write anything. Or, we would change the angle of the piece to be more focused on the destination, briefly mentioning the hotel. I think this is a classy approach still. Something else to note is that the hotel, of course, knows you’re there and is putting on their best performance.

20 more comments...

Ready for more?